When the real estate market is falling, it can feel like a terrible time to make a move.Your home may be worth less than it was a year ago. Headlines are negative. Buyers are cautious. And most homeowners would understandably prefer to sell when prices are higher.But if you're planning to sell one property and buy a more expensive one, a down market can actually work in your favour.This is particularly important for condo owners hoping to move into a townhouse.For years, I've watched first-time buyers purchase condos because townhouses and detached homes were simply too expensive. The down payments were larger, the mortgages were harder to qualify for, and the gap between property types kept getting wider.Today, we're seeing almost the opposite.Prices have fallen significantly across the Fraser Valley, and while that has obviously been painful for existing homeowners, it has also created an opportunity for people trying to move up the property ladder.
Townhouse: $764,500That creates a price gap of approximately $314,500.A year ago, the same general comparison was closer to:Condo: $498,000
Townhouse: $829,500That's a gap of approximately $331,500.In other words, the gap between the condo and townhouse has shrunk by roughly $17,000 in only a year.Your condo may be worth less.But the property you're trying to buy has fallen by even more dollars.And compared with the strongest years of the market, the difference can become much larger.
The Price of Your Condo Isn't the Only Number That Matters
One of the biggest mistakes move-up buyers make is focusing exclusively on what has happened to the value of their current home.Imagine your condo has fallen by $50,000.That's obviously disappointing.But what if the townhouse you want to buy has fallen by $75,000?Or the detached home has fallen by $150,000?You may be selling your existing property for less, but you're also purchasing your next property for substantially less.For someone moving up, the most important number isn't necessarily the value of either property.It's the gap between them.Falling Prices Can Actually Shrink the Gap
Different neighbourhoods experience different price declines.For example, detached home prices in Cloverdale have fallen much less recently than detached prices in Mission.But within individual neighbourhoods, condos, townhouses and detached homes will often experience declines that are reasonably similar on a percentage basis.And that's where the math becomes interesting.Let's say a $500,000 condo and a $1.5 million detached home both fall by 10%.The condo loses $50,000.That hurts.But the detached home loses $150,000.Suddenly, the dollar gap between the two properties has shrunk by $100,000.That's why a declining market can sometimes be significantly better for someone moving up than a rapidly appreciating market.The Opportunity May Be Condo to Townhouse
I'm not suggesting every condo owner can suddenly jump straight into a detached home.For many people, that's still unrealistic.Here in Surrey, you might be selling a condo around the mid-$400,000 range while a typical detached home is still well above $1 million.That's a massive jump.A townhouse, however, may be much more achievable.Using current benchmark prices, let's look at the approximate cost of moving from a Surrey condo worth around $450,000 into a townhouse worth approximately $764,500.The purchase price is only the beginning.Start With the Equity in Your Condo
The first question is how much money you'll actually have available after selling your condo.Start with the sale price and subtract your selling expenses.Real estate fees can vary considerably depending on the agent and services provided, but for this example I'm using a commission structure of 7% on the first $100,000 and 3% on the balance.On a condo around this price, that works out to approximately $17,500 plus GST.That leaves approximately $432,000 before paying off your mortgage.Next, subtract whatever remains owing on that mortgage.You'll also need to determine whether your lender will charge a penalty for breaking your existing mortgage early.Depending on your mortgage, that could be as little as three months' interest or potentially a much larger interest rate differential penalty.What's left after those expenses and your mortgage are paid becomes the equity available toward your next purchase.Don't Forget Property Transfer Tax
Selling isn't the only side of the transaction with expenses.In BC, purchasing a $764,500 townhouse would generally result in approximately $13,290 of property transfer tax before considering whether you qualify for any available exemptions.That's cash you'll need to account for in addition to your down payment.You'll also need legal services to complete both transactions.For this example, I'd set aside roughly another $2,500 for legal and conveyancing expenses.Very quickly, you can be north of $30,000 in transaction costs associated with selling one property and purchasing another.That's why it's important to calculate the entire move rather than simply comparing sale prices.How Much Down Payment Would You Need?
A 20% down payment on a $764,500 townhouse would be $152,900.Putting down 20% allows you to avoid mortgage default insurance.A smaller down payment may make the move possible with substantially less cash upfront, but mortgage default insurance would generally be added to the mortgage principal.That means there's a trade-off.A smaller down payment makes it easier to complete the purchase today, but it increases the amount you'll ultimately finance.This is where sitting down with a good mortgage professional before selling your existing property becomes extremely important.What Income Would You Need?
The next hurdle is qualification.Let's assume the townhouse costs $764,500 and you're able to obtain a mortgage rate around 4.25%.Because of Canada's mortgage stress test, you wouldn't simply qualify using your actual mortgage payment.You would need to qualify at a higher rate.Using a qualifying rate around 6.25%, a buyer making the minimum down payment could require household income somewhere around $160,000 to $165,000 per year, depending on their other debts and financial circumstances.With 20% down, that estimated income requirement could fall closer to approximately $134,000 to $140,000.Those are significant household incomes, but they're also consistent with what I'm seeing among many townhouse buyers today, particularly couples purchasing together.Now Compare Those Numbers With a Year Ago
This is where the move-up opportunity becomes much more interesting.Today, we're using approximately:Condo: $450,000Townhouse: $764,500That creates a price gap of approximately $314,500.A year ago, the same general comparison was closer to:Condo: $498,000
Townhouse: $829,500That's a gap of approximately $331,500.In other words, the gap between the condo and townhouse has shrunk by roughly $17,000 in only a year.Your condo may be worth less.But the property you're trying to buy has fallen by even more dollars.And compared with the strongest years of the market, the difference can become much larger.
A "Good" Market Can Be Terrible for Move-Up Buyers
This is the part that often gets overlooked.When homeowners tell me they're going to wait until the market gets better before moving, my next question is usually: better for whom?If the market starts rising rapidly again, your condo may appreciate.Great.But there's a good chance the townhouse you're trying to buy will appreciate too.Because the townhouse starts at a higher price, the same percentage increase can add considerably more dollars to its value.The gap between the two properties can begin widening again.And that's exactly what happened to many homeowners during the strongest years of the market.Their condo increased in value, but the townhouse or detached home they wanted increased by even more.They were getting richer on paper while simultaneously getting further away from the home they actually wanted.A Slower Market Has Other Advantages
Price isn't the only potential advantage.A slower market generally gives move-up buyers more time.You may have more properties to choose from. You may be able to negotiate on price. You may be able to include reasonable conditions in your offer. And you're less likely to be competing against multiple buyers throwing unconditional offers at the same property.During a rapidly appreciating market, those advantages can disappear quickly.That's why waiting for the headlines to tell you the real estate market is "good" again isn't necessarily the safest strategy.By the time everyone agrees the market is good, buyers may already be competing against each other again.Moving Up Is About the Gap, Not the Headline Price
If you're thinking about moving from a condo into a townhouse, don't simply ask:"What is my condo worth?"Ask:"What is my condo worth, what does the townhouse I want cost, and what is the difference between those two numbers?"Then calculate the transaction costs, your available equity, your new mortgage and the income required to qualify.That's the real move-up calculation.A declining market certainly creates losers, particularly for homeowners who bought near the peak and now need to sell.But the same market can create opportunities for someone purchasing their first home or moving into a more expensive property.Your current home may be worth less than it was before.The important question is whether the home you actually want has fallen by even more.Because sometimes a "bad" real estate market can be exactly what you need to make your next move.Written by:
Steve Karrasch PREC
Karrasch Real Properties Team
Macdonald Realty
Karrasch Real Properties Team
Macdonald Realty